At Newport cover
Recorded
Released

The composer Ned Rorem is reputed to have said that both Ella Fitzgerald and Billie Holiday had “perfect pitch: in Ella’s case, it was whatever pitch the composer had written; in Billie’s case, it was whatever pitch she chose to sing.” The story may be apocryphal, but the assessment is right on: Ella Fitzgerald is probably the most celebrated jazz singer in history, and it’s largely because of the disciplined sweetness and clarity of her voice, and her exquisite control over it. She was a pure gift to any songwriter whose work she chose to interpret. Billie Holiday, on the other hand, is almost equally celebrated for nearly the opposite reason: her voice was a gritty conveyor of sadness and resignation, and she swiped at pitches impressionistically more than she landed on them with precision. This live album documents their sets at the 1957 Newport Jazz festival, and offers a nice opportunity to compare and contrast their highly disparate styles.

Rick Anderson

Recommended by

Suggestions
Lock My Heart cover

Lock My Heart

Dick Hyman, Heather Masse
Ella & Duke at the Côte d'Azur cover

Ella & Duke at the Côte d'Azur

Duke Ellington, Ella Fitzgerald
Here Comes The Sun cover

Here Comes The Sun

Monty Alexander
Eight Track III cover

Eight Track III

Dave Stryker
Handful Of Stars, A cover

Handful Of Stars, A

Aaron Weinstein
Open Book cover

Open Book

Fred Hersch
Ella and Louis cover

Ella and Louis

Ella Fitzgerald, Louis Armstrong
Catch Me If You Can cover

Catch Me If You Can

Jon Hamar, Jeff Hamilton, Tamir Hendleman