Pinkerton

Released

Weezer thought they were making their own In Utero with Pinkerton – an underproduced audience shedding course corrective to out of control fame. In that, they succeeded a little too much. While it took years for this record to find appreciation with a future generation of emo fans, for better and for worse, it is very much of its time. The hooks that had propelled Weezer into the big leagues were still there, heard on “No Other One” and “Tired of Sex.” But that only makes the poison lyrics harder to swallow. Those songs, along with “Pink Triangle” and “Across the Sea” shine a harsh spotlight on the worst tendencies of the archetypal misogynist nice guy, and the words read like a teenage stalker’s diary. But Pinkerton’s unflinching, ugly honesty left quite an impression, and emo bands would retread its difficult themes and melodies for years after.

Joshua Levine

Suggestions
Dead Man’s Pop cover

Dead Man’s Pop

The Replacements
Up the Bracket cover

Up the Bracket

The Libertines
Snap! cover

Snap!

The Jam
Hawk cover

Hawk

Isobel Campbell, Mark Lanegan
Mass Romantic cover

Mass Romantic

The New Pornographers
Folie À Deux cover

Folie À Deux

Fall Out Boy
Council Skies cover

Council Skies

Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds